Best-Rated Hotels in Edinburgh for 2025
Updated 9 July 2026 · 36 real hotels
Edinburgh's highest-rated hotels span a wide range of styles, from a unique floating hotel in Leith to iconic five-star landmarks in the New Town and Old Town. Every property on this list holds a traveller score of 4.8 or above out of 5, reflecting consistently outstanding guest satisfaction. Whether you seek a grand historic address or a well-appointed self-catering apartment, Edinburgh delivers.
Your stay in Édimbourg, in one conversation
Charlize builds hotels, activities and dining around your wishes, dates and budget.
Edinburgh's Most Praised Hotels, Ranked by Traveller Satisfaction
Edinburgh is a city of dramatic contrasts: medieval closes and Georgian crescents, volcanic rock and coastal harbour, centuries-old pubs and acclaimed modern restaurants. Its hotels reflect that same variety. The properties on this page have been filtered and ranked solely on the basis of real, verified traveller scores, so every recommendation here represents a place where guests consistently leave happy. Scores range from a perfect 5 out of 5 down to a still-exceptional 4.8 out of 5, meaning the gap between first and last place is remarkably small.
The selection covers several distinct Edinburgh neighbourhoods. Leith, the city's revitalised port district, is home to the extraordinary Fingal, a converted lighthouse tender moored permanently at the quayside. The atmospheric Old Town, within walking distance of the Royal Mile and Edinburgh Castle, offers the design-led Market Street Hotel. The elegant Georgian New Town features The Balmoral Hotel, one of Scotland's most recognisable addresses, as well as the Braid Apartments by Mansley for those preferring self-catering flexibility. Further out, Prestonfield House sits in private parkland near Holyrood Park, while properties in Trinity and across the wider city round out a list that suits different budgets, travel styles and lengths of stay.
Our selection in Édimbourg
| Hotel | Area | Rating | Price / night |
|---|---|---|---|
| BrewDog DogHouse Edinburgh ★★★★ | Édimbourg | ★ 4.9 | 323 €/nuit |
| Market Street Hotel ★★★★ | Vieille ville d’Édimbourg | ★ 4.9 | 329 €/nuit |
| RÌGH Residences ★★★★ | New Town | ★ 4.9 | 283 €/nuit |
| 3 Johns Place Townhouse ★★★★ | Leith | ★ 4.8 | 176 €/nuit |
| 4 Friends House ★★ | Trinity | ★ 4.8 | 141 €/nuit |
| Tynecastle Park Hotel ★★★★ | Gorgie | ★ 4.8 | 190 €/nuit |
| Forth House by Supercity Aparthotels ★★★★ | Édimbourg | ★ 4.8 | 267 €/nuit |
| The Scott ★★★★ | Édimbourg | ★ 4.8 | 298 €/nuit |
| Destiny Scotland George IV Apartments ★★★★ | Vieille ville d’Édimbourg | ★ 4.8 | 248 €/nuit |
| The Resident Edinburgh ★★★★ | West End | ★ 4.8 | 273 €/nuit |
Frequently asked questions
Which Edinburgh hotel has the highest traveller rating on this list?+
Fingal, a luxury floating hotel moored in Leith, holds the top spot with a perfect score of 5 out of 5 from travellers. It is a five-star property converted from a historic lighthouse tender ship, offering a genuinely one-of-a-kind setting that guests consistently rate as exceptional. Nightly rates start from around 678 euros, placing it in the premium tier while remaining more affordable than some other five-star options in the city.
Are there well-rated Edinburgh hotels that are more budget-friendly?+
Yes. The 4 Friends House in the Trinity neighbourhood holds a strong 4.8 out of 5 traveller score and has rates from around 238 euros per night, making it by far the most affordable property on this curated list. It is rated two stars, so expectations around services and facilities should be set accordingly, but guest satisfaction figures show that visitors who choose it are genuinely pleased with their stay.
What is the best-rated hotel in Edinburgh's Old Town?+
Among the properties on this list, Market Street Hotel in the Old Town stands out with a traveller score of 4.9 out of 5. It is a four-star hotel located in the heart of the historic city centre, within easy reach of the Royal Mile, Edinburgh Castle, and the Grassmarket. Rates are around 423 euros per night, positioning it as a premium but not ultra-luxury option for guests who prioritise location and high satisfaction.
Which highly-rated Edinburgh hotels are good for longer stays or self-catering?+
Two properties on this list cater particularly well to guests who want more space or self-catering facilities. Braid Apartments by Mansley in the New Town holds a 4.8 out of 5 score and offers apartment-style accommodation at around 487 euros per night. Forth House by Supercity Aparthotels, also rated 4.8 out of 5, provides a similar self-catering experience at around 427 euros per night. Both are four-star rated and suit business travellers, families or anyone staying for several nights who appreciates a kitchen and more living space.