Best-Rated Hotels in Syracuse, Italy
Updated 5 July 2026 · 36 real hotels
Syracuse rewards travellers with a strong selection of highly rated hotels, several of which hold perfect or near-perfect scores from verified guests. Options range from intimate B&Bs on the island of Ortigia to well-reviewed properties across the wider city, covering a broad spread of budgets.
Your stay in Syracuse, in one conversation
Charlize builds hotels, activities and dining around your wishes, dates and budget.
Why traveller scores matter in Syracuse
Syracuse is one of Sicily's most layered destinations, where ancient Greek theatres, Baroque piazzas and the car-free island of Ortigia sit within a short walk of each other. With so much history packed into a compact area, choosing a well-rated hotel means more than just a comfortable bed: it often means attentive hosts who know the city deeply and properties that genuinely deliver on their promise.
The hotels listed here have been filtered and ranked by real traveller scores, so every property on this page earned its place through verified guest feedback. Ortigia dominates the top results, which reflects how central that island is to the Syracuse experience, but solid options also appear in Santa Lucia, Néapolis and Grottasanta for travellers who prefer a quieter or more budget-conscious base.
Our selection in Syracuse
A real selection, real prices, from the most affordable to the showstopper.
| Hotel | Area | Rating | Price / night |
|---|---|---|---|
| L'Attico di Matilde | Syracuse | ★ 4.6 | 72 €/nuit |
| Vegan B&B | Syracuse | ★ 4.7 | 77 €/nuit |
| Antares Bed And Breakfast | Syracuse | ★ 4.8 | 78 €/nuit |
| B&B Kosmos ★★★ | Epipoli | ★ 4.8 | 83 €/nuit |
| Hotiday Siracusa Floridia | Syracuse | ★ 5 | 86 €/nuit |
| Hotiday Siracusa A'Storia | Syracuse | ★ 4.3 | 87 €/nuit |
| Nostos rooms & Apartments ★★★ | Santa Lucia | ★ 4.5 | 97 €/nuit |
| Archimede's Rooms | Néapolis | ★ 4.5 | 97 €/nuit |
| B&B Il Tempio di Athena | Néapolis | ★ 4.6 | 102 €/nuit |
| B&B Casa D'Alleri ★★★ | Ortigia | ★ 4.5 | 107 €/nuit |
Frequently asked questions
Which hotels in Syracuse have a perfect 5/5 traveller score?+
Three properties currently hold a 5/5 score from verified guests: Dimora Archimedea in the Néapolis area, Maniace Boutique Hotel Ortigia UNA Esperienze on the island of Ortigia, Calafatari B&B in Santa Lucia, and Maecò Ortigia B&B also on Ortigia. Each represents a different price point and neighbourhood, so the choice depends on your preferred location and budget rather than any difference in guest satisfaction.
Is Ortigia the best area to stay for highly rated hotels in Syracuse?+
Ortigia concentrates several of the top-rated options, including Maniace Boutique Hotel, Maecò Ortigia B&B, Palazzo Gilistro and Dimore delle Zagare Ortigia, all scoring 4.9 or higher. The island puts you within walking distance of the Cathedral, the Fonte Aretusa and the main restaurant strip, which guests consistently praise. That said, properties outside Ortigia such as Dimora Archimedea near Néapolis and Syraka Hotel in Grottasanta also achieve near-perfect scores, so high satisfaction is not exclusive to the island.
What is the most affordable highly rated hotel in Syracuse?+
Among the properties on this list, Syraka Hotel LR Collection in Grottasanta starts from around 112 euros per night and holds a 4.9/5 traveller score, making it the most budget-friendly entry. PhotoGuest, a 3-star property in the broader Syracuse area, comes close at approximately 113 euros per night with the same 4.9/5 rating. Both options show that strong guest satisfaction is achievable without staying in a premium boutique.
How do boutique hotels in Syracuse compare to B&Bs in terms of traveller ratings?+
Based on the scores here, both formats perform equally well. Boutique hotels such as Maniace Boutique Hotel Ortigia and Palazzo Gilistro earn 5/5 and 4.9/5 respectively, while B&Bs like Calafatari and Maecò Ortigia match or equal those figures. The key difference tends to be price and the style of service: boutique hotels generally offer more facilities and a higher nightly rate, whereas B&Bs deliver a more personal, host-led experience at a comparatively lower cost. Either format can clearly deliver outstanding guest satisfaction in Syracuse.