Best-Rated Hotels in Reykjavik: Top Picks
Updated 7 November 2026 · 36 real hotels
Reykjavik's best-rated hotels span a wide range of budgets and styles, all sharing one thing: consistently outstanding guest satisfaction. Nordic Apartments and The Retreat at Blue Lagoon Iceland both sit at the top of traveller scores, while options like Lighthouse Inn and Miðgarður by Center Hotels deliver strong ratings at more accessible price points. Whether you seek a central base or a secluded luxury escape, Reykjavik has a highly rated option for you.
Your stay in Reykjavik, in one conversation
Charlize builds hotels, activities and dining around your wishes, dates and budget.
Reykjavik's Highest-Rated Hotels by Traveller Score
Planning a trip to Iceland's vibrant capital means choosing from a surprisingly diverse hotel scene, one where guest satisfaction scores vary considerably. This selection cuts through the noise by showcasing only the properties that have earned the strongest traveller ratings, so you can book with confidence rather than guesswork. From a compact 2-star apartment in the heart of the city centre to a legendary 5-star geothermal retreat near the Blue Lagoon, the options below represent what real guests have rated most highly.
What unites these hotels is not a single price bracket or star category, but a track record of leaving guests genuinely satisfied. A few key patterns emerge: central locations in Reykjavik's walkable downtown tend to score well for convenience, while properties that offer something distinctive, such as spa access, home-style apartment living, or attentive boutique service, consistently earn praise. Use the guest ratings alongside location and nightly rate to find the property that best fits your travel style and budget.
Our selection in Reykjavik
A real selection, real prices, from the most affordable to the showstopper.
| Hotel | Area | Rating | Price / night |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fisherman's Village ★★★ | Garðabær | ★ 4.6 | 111 €/nuit |
| CityHub Reykjavik ★★ | Centre-ville de Reykjavik | ★ 4.6 | 120 €/nuit |
| Hotel Vellir ★★★ | Hafnarfjördur | ★ 4.5 | 125 €/nuit |
| Lighthouse Inn ★★★★ | — | ★ 4.8 | 141 €/nuit |
| Guesthouse Sunna ★★★ | Centre-ville de Reykjavik | ★ 4.6 | 145 €/nuit |
| Rey Apartments ★★★ | Centre-ville de Reykjavik | ★ 4.6 | 150 €/nuit |
| Fosshotel Reykjavik ★★★★ | Reykjavik | ★ 4.5 | 156 €/nuit |
| Miðgarður by Center Hotels ★★★★ | Reykjavik | ★ 4.7 | 157 €/nuit |
| Center Hotels Klöpp ★★★ | Centre-ville de Reykjavik | ★ 4.5 | 161 €/nuit |
| Thingholt Hotel Apartments from Center Hotels ★★★★ | Centre-ville de Reykjavik | ★ 4.6 | 163 €/nuit |
Our hotel profiles in Reykjavik
Frequently asked questions
Which hotel in Reykjavik has the highest traveller rating?+
Two properties share the top spot in guest satisfaction scores: Nordic Apartments, a 2-star aparthotel in the city centre priced around 235 euros per night, and The Retreat at Blue Lagoon Iceland, a 5-star luxury resort near Grindavik starting at approximately 1,538 euros per night. Both carry a 4.9 out of 5 rating from travellers, making them the highest-rated options in this selection despite being at opposite ends of the price and category spectrum.
Are there well-rated hotels in Reykjavik that are more budget-friendly?+
Yes. Lighthouse Inn, rated 4.8 out of 5, is the most affordable option in this selection at around 141 euros per night. Miðgarður by Center Hotels, a 4-star property rated 4.7 out of 5, is also competitively priced at approximately 157 euros per night. Hotel Lotus in Háaleiti offers a 4.8 rating at around 173 euros per night. All three deliver strong guest satisfaction without requiring a premium outlay.
What is the best-rated hotel in Reykjavik's city centre specifically?+
Among city-centre properties, Nordic Apartments leads with a 4.9 out of 5 traveller rating. Reykjavik Residence Apartment Hotel and Hotel Reykjavik Saga both hold a 4.8 out of 5 rating and are also located in the city centre, priced at around 227 euros and 253 euros per night respectively. These three options offer a combination of central positioning and high guest approval, making them strong choices for travellers who want to explore Reykjavik on foot.
Is The Retreat at Blue Lagoon Iceland worth its high price given its guest rating?+
The Retreat at Blue Lagoon Iceland holds a 4.9 out of 5 traveller rating, the joint-highest in this selection, and is a 5-star property located in Grindavik, close to the famous Blue Lagoon geothermal spa. At roughly 1,538 euros per night, it is by far the most expensive hotel listed here. Whether the price represents value depends entirely on your priorities: guests who have rated it so highly clearly feel the experience justifies the cost, but travellers seeking strong satisfaction at a lower price point will find well-rated alternatives within Reykjavik's city centre.